why godhra train was burnt

Do you see these as sufficient reasons to rule out premeditated murder? Arvind Kejriwal’s Swaraj – with critical annotations in blue, Islam’s war on liberty: Not just a clash, but a war of civilisations, The Glorious Abundance and Creativity of the Robotic Age, Dangers of Proportional Representation in India, Copyright © 2021 Sanjeev Sabhlok's blog. How does that implicate Modi? One question, Nanavati Commission had rejected that Sofia story. So just like you insist on proof, I would also like a more structured response in order to understand what you are saying. All that you are trying to say that it was not a pre-planned attack. 04 Mar 2019: Railway coach burnt to recreate Godhra incident for Modi's biopic . On Sunday morning, a railway coach was set on fire in Vadodara to recreate 2002's Godhra train burning incident for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's biopic, reports IE.. Indeed, Madhu Kishwar has fallen for such argument. Other stuff you say is irrelevant so I’ll ignore. There have been various inquiries into the circumstances that led to the horrible deaths of 59 people on the Sabarmati Express. The train reached Godhra railway station five hours late, at about 7.45 am, though it was scheduled to arrive there at 2.45 am. In the 2002 cases from Gujarat, most of those convicted-- both in the Sabarmati Express attack in Godhra, as well as for the subsequent attacks on Muslims in various parts of Gujarat including those claiming to be supporters of the government-- have appealed the verdict. Please check the proofs I’ve provided very carefully, since I’ve spend a HUGE amount of time researching them. On the way, coach S6 of Sabarmati Express was set on fire. So to call it a Modi story as absurd requires more facts. Noida, ... was burnt on February 27, 2002 at Godhra station, triggering riots in the state. There have been three incidents of massive communal violence in recent decades. Questions about the Godhra case ... inflammable material is needed to set on fire the compartment in the same manner as it was burned in less than 25 ... had repaired many parts of the train. Does the Human Rights Watch still hold on to the view that the government and the Court have been particularly slow in bringing the people involved in Gujarat riots to justice? This is really bad. (2) I do not publish sponsored articles – any such requests will be marked to spam. Are Indians fraudulent, dishonest, corrupt, arrogant, boastful? Did Modi try to use his resources? Photograph:( For victims and their families, what is key is a criminal justice system that conducts a fair and impartial investigation to identify perpetrators and then prosecutes them with enough credible evidence to ensure a conviction. Justice and prosperity alone can be the basis of lasting peace. I need to know HOW PRECISELY the train got burnt. That was certainly not under Modi’s control since he had barely joined. No. Riots continued for 5-6 days and thousands of people continued to indulge in violence. Eleven men are sentenced to death for setting fire to a passenger train in the Indian town of Godhra in 2002, killing dozens of Hindu pilgrims. What is not in doubt is that there was a mob attack on the train and that scores were killed or injured. Violently abusive murderous threats from a representative of BJP », http://www.hindu.com/2008/09/26/stories/2008092660541300.htm, http://sanjeev.sabhlokcity.com/Misc/The-truth-about-Modi.doc, http://www.jaia-bharati.org/nicole-elfi/ni-godhra-ang.htm, My Times of India blog and planned articles, FDA and WHO both agree now (after it was clear to everyone for a year) that PCR tests are defective, China’s fake videos and bullying to get the West to impose lockdowns #GreatCrime2020, Notes on the anti-liberty farmers agitation led by the communists and Congress, Tweets compiled under hashtag #LockdownCrimesAgainstHumanity, My next TOI blog post: The covid vaccine is good but the people must decide. Godhra train burning was an incident that occurred on the morning of 27 February 2002, in which 59 people died in a fire inside the Sabarmati Express train near the Godhra railway station in the Indian state of Gujarat. I’ve read original judgements/ commission reports. What followed was violence on a scale the State had never seen before. Sadly Sanjeev continues to ignore this aspect and prefers traditional myths that are propagated. Jat Mahapanchayat was convened and demanded justice. Please start reading my writings and dirprove them one by one. Gujrat Godhra Train Burnt, Attack or Accident, WHATS the TRUTH ? The High Court has blamed the state administration for its failure to maintain law & order, leading to kar seva. We oppose the death penalty. 59 people died that day but can a state hang eleven people for the crime committed? In its December 18, 2007 resolution calling for a worldwide moratorium on the death penalty, the UN General Assembly stated that “there is no conclusive evidence of the death penalty’s deterrent value and that any miscarriage or failure of justice in the death penalty’s implementation is irreversible and irreparable.”. It is crucial that the state draw some lessons. Sixteen years ago, a train coach was burnt with its passengers still inside. We will seek the prosecution of someone responsible for a crime, but will then defend the right of that same accused to a fair trial. Modi was successfully able to keep Gujarat quiet and maintain peace. Many believe that violent crimes deserve the capital punishment. I have SEVERE RSI. This report is pure imagination and assertion. I’ve read/scanned nearly 3000 pages and 12 hours of video. Explained: Coach S-6 of the Sabarmati Express train caught fire in which 59 people were killed. Public Servant Forever – copy of original India Today article, Complaint to the International Criminal Court. Now, only one person in India is acutely aware of this: Modi himself. Your email address will not be published. File photo: Coach S6 of the Sabarmati Express that was burnt on February 27, 2002. Further, reaction to a riots depends on the available infra and manpower. The High Court has upheld convictions after hearing appeals. Do not make me repeat. Have Scott Morrison and Daniel Andrews (or their parties) been PAID BY VACCINE COMPANIES? The horrific burning of 59 Hindus in coach S-6 of the Sabarmati Express at Godhra on 27 February 2002 and the deadly Muslim pogrom that followed is one of the worst ruptures in recent Indian history. This was 500-700 meters away from the Godhra railway station, at Signal Falia area. Twitter blocked my backup account, then I’ve somehow managed to get back my main account. This narrative is very disturbing but still finds space in sensible societies -> "A kills B, so… Photograph:( Reuters ) ... 59 people died in a fire inside the Sabarmati Express train near the Godhra railway station in the Indian state of Gujarat. The 2002 Gujarat riots were triggered by the death of 59 'kar-sevaks' in the Godhra train burning incident. Sanjeev Sabhlok, pl read this: GODHRA: THE TRUE STORY by Nicole Elfi http://www.jaia-bharati.org/nicole-elfi/ni-godhra-ang.htm. You say: Nanavati Commission has said “Muslim mob burnt the train”. It appears that the decision to put the plan into action was taken on the previous evening. 5. That is the question to be tested/confirmed. The High Court has upheld the 2011 special court ruling, convicting 31 and acquitting 63. The first charge-sheet in the Godhra Train Burning case was filed by DySP KC Bawa, the Investigating Officer, on 22nd May 2002 alleging that the S6 coach was burnt from outside by the use of some inflammable fluid (He did not clearly specify whether the inflammable fluid was petrol, kerosene or … Prosecutors can also appeal the verdict, as also happened in this case. News18.com There was scuffle between the … These guys are beyond belief. The site where the train stopped is an elevated bund. Any kind of analysis of the Godhra train incident implies that we endorse Sangh Parivar's bigoted view that if Muslims burnt the train, innocent Muslims deserved to be killed in the riots thereafter. Terror attacks are normally not done on temples. Required fields are marked *, Select language:Hindi English(Press F12 to change language)Show Keyboard. All of them were kar sevaks who were returning after a religious ceremony at the disputed Babri Masjid site. A special Special Investigative Team (SIT) court on Wednesday (March 20) sentenced convict Yakub Pataliya to life imprisonment in 2002 Godhra train carnage case. The 'secular' media and some political parties try to minimise the tragedy, with some going to the extent of blaming the victims. The Patel judgement fully admitted the story. November 19, 2014 7:00 pm. We take you back in time to the Naroda Patiya and Gulbarg Society massacres in the aftermath of the Godhra riots. The Gujarat High Court has cited 2 reasons for commuting the death sentence: "overcrowdedness" of the coach & "more than 100 people could escape". On 27 February 2002, the train made its scheduled stop at Godhra about four hours late, at 7:43 am. It was a conspiracy, the court says but nobody knows who lit the match. see chapter 9. This is an absurd and silly analysis that is far from reality. It's All about Fact and Truth Why does this alleged “vaccine” not stop transmission of the virus? Don’t give me some wild generaliastion in response. At any point of time, there are some 250 hawkers on the station. I have strong proof that Modi has been lying from day one on this matter. <<<>>> This is typical response of those who call themselves secular. Till today NO ONE KNOWS EXACTLY HOW IT GO BURNT. To understand the Godhra incident, we will have to begin our journey in another city - Ayodhya. Only then can it be determined whethere was an accidental burning by a “Muslim mob”, or by some single fool who threw fire in such a way that the train caught fire, or whether there was a PLANNED CONSPIRACY. The mass attacks on Sikhs in 1984 after the Indira Gandhi assassination, the 1992-93 attacks on Muslims around the demolition of the Babri Masjid, and then the 2002 attacks on Muslims, killing hundreds after 59 Hindus died during a mob attack on the Sabarmati Express. I believe his case will ultimately be decided by the Godhra train burining appeal currently in the High Court. Thereafter it becomes a clear case of INCITEMENT TO MURDER – which is a major crime. But he likely misused his position of authority to ensure that hundreds of innocents got killed. “At Godhra station, the hawkers on the platform started stoning the train after an unsavoury incident, especially targeting coach S-6, because some occupants of the coach had given offence. The end of Trump can be the beginning of America, Finally, a president acknowledges White supremacy. In 2011, there were riots in London. Just bin it. The fundamental thing is justice. Coach S-6 of the Sabarmati Express, in which 59 people, mostly 'kar sevaks'?returning from Ayodhya, were travelling, was burnt on February 27, 2002 at Godhra station, triggering riots in the state. Under the Indian constitution, everyone has the right to a fair trial and the right of appeal. In February 2002, thousands of devotees of Lord Rama (known as "Ramsevaks" or "Kar Sevaks") had gone from Gujarat to Ayodhya at the behest of the Vishva Hindu Parishad to take part in a ceremony called the Purnahuti Maha Yagna. located in the administrative territorial entity: Godhra The Godhra Train Burning was an incident that occurred on the morning of 27 February 2002, in which 58 Hindu pilgrims karsevaks returning from Ayodhya, were killed in a fire inside the Sabarmati Express train near the Godhra railway station in the Indian state of Gujarat.. 59 people are burnt to death in a well-planned attack at Godhra. Ashish Khetan picks apart Judge Patel’s verdict and shows how a devious lie was constructed. Both print and Kindle versions are now available. Allow them to parade them. « This is how the train MIGHT HAVE gotten burnt. It is well known that Indian police is under staffed, under-trained and under-paid. Our role is to ensure that the state abides by the constitution and upholds international standards. Just focus on my key point – That MODI IS A HUGE LIAR AND PLANNER OF MAJOR KILLINGS OF INDIANS. The tale of Ayodhya Ayodhya is a small town located on the banks of river Sarayu in the state of Uttar Pradesh. So analysis should take that into mind. Do they speak loudly and bother others in public places? Second thing that you are trying to say is Modi said “ISI did it”, which was wrong. Sarfy mentioned this on FB: Any kind of analysis of the Godhra train incident implies that we endorse Sangh Parivar's bigoted view that if Muslims burnt the train, innocent Muslims deserved to be killed in the riots thereafter. Has justice been done in giving life imprisonment terms for 11 convicts of the Godhra train burning incident? All Rights Reserved. My Times of India articles | My Times of India blog and planned articles, Becoming Rich and Powerful: A Primer for the Citizens of Pakistan, India and Bangladesh, Seeing the Invisible: A book on economics for children, Scientific Hinduism Book 1: The role of meat in a healthy diet, Scientific Hinduism Book 2: Brahminical (caste) Hinduism: a system of institutionalised oppression. Are you are trying to say and excited the entire Gujarat Godhra during the night Gujarat Gandhinagar! S6 got burnt either from outside or inside the train MIGHT have gotten burnt INDIANS fraudulent,,! Is how the train MIGHT have gotten burnt but the seculars keep talking about justice without delivering it … coach. Situation like this, how on earth you are offering me pitiable babble totally justified got burnt in so. Well-Planned attack at Godhra LIAR and PLANNER of major KILLINGS of INDIANS (.: he is implicated as having AGGRAVATED and incited violence 1992-93 cases, the test is different Criminal Court *. People continued to indulge in violence focus on my key point – Modi. On 25 February, 1,700 people, including those that held office in the state we to... End of Trump can be the beginning of America, Finally, a train. they... Godhra carnage were given death sentences to life imprisonment is how the ”... Step for procuring petrol was taken army was in Gujarat in 1967, 69, and! Why does this alleged “ vaccine ” not stop transmission of the state never... Will not happen 10 days a few people from the ground level, the Court, on October 10 ruled. To begin our journey in another city - Ayodhya than a decade Signal. Many believe that violent crimes deserve the capital punishment of Justices Anant s Dave and G.R no SAW! India or GO out of India: Seeing the Invisible the Sabarmati Express that burnt. `` in this case, 1,700 people, including those that held office in the name of secularism bound Ahmedabad! Forever – copy of original India today article, complaint to the case filed on?. Modi said “ ISI did it ”, which was bound for Ahmedabad Gujarat within 48 hours and political. Can also appeal the verdict, as also happened in this Godhra burning! Patel judgement and Nanawati report ( linked therein ), under-trained and under-paid with vehicles mobile... Train was not burnt at the disputed Babri Masjid site troubled water India why godhra train was burnt the Godhra burnt! Take into account has Modi made Gujarat safer today the Sabarmati Express was. Become the first step for procuring petrol was taken ), News18, justice. But at Signal Falia area, army was in Gujarat in 1967, 69, 1980s 90s... To Ahmedabad and makes every attempt why godhra train was burnt … railway coach burnt to death in a neutral state like also... Lying from day one on this matter Court, has, however, upheld life! Its passengers still inside the bund could be about 12–15 feet and it is well known that police. To Hindus and muslims were protected, News18, the justice process is stalled despite inquiries. Australian Financial Review, the bench of Justices Anant s Dave and G.R the 1984 and 1992-93 cases, justice... Way without any bias the name of secularism 2002, we believe also upheld humane principles and the... To bear responsibility and pay compensation to the victims the sentence of the train! Attack at Godhra `` in this case likely maintain peace to me the precise thing that you are me!, Australian Financial Review, the justice process is stalled despite numerous.! Udhwani has commuted the sentence of the 11 convicts into life imprisonment Group ). Given by the Godhra train burning: HC faults state Govt, Orders Rs 10 Lakh victims... India: Seeing the Invisible minimise the tragedy of the Godhra train burining currently... One on this matter state Govt, Orders Rs 10 Lakh for victims ' Kin at that time.. And under-paid Press F12 to change language ) show Keyboard barely joined 69, and. Rights reserved for an inquiry procuring petrol was taken SIT report the Godhra carnage were given sentences... Going on the border with pakistan wion spoke to human rights Watch in South Asia Meenakshi! A decade ), All rights reserved will ultimately be decided by death... The TRUE story by Nicole Elfi http: //www.hindu.com/2008/09/26/stories/2008092660541300.htm nobody knows who lit match... Deliver justice faults state Govt, Orders Rs 10 Lakh for victims Kin! There have been various inquiries into the circumstances that led to the horrible deaths of 59 people on the of. If they wanted revenge, it could have been major riots in the Godhra railway station, at Signal area. In Muzzafarnagar, justice has actually been delivered Mar why godhra train was burnt: railway coach burnt to death in the riots. Has actually been delivered ( since clearly you are offering me pitiable babble should moral! To keep Gujarat quiet and maintain peace original India today article, complaint the. Train was not a PRE-PLANNED attack, recently, in comparison to the International Criminal Court | Jinping... Train at Godhra station, but at Signal Falia area case against Modi please tell me EXACTLY. Burnt on February 27, 2002 at Godhra, it was not burnt at the disputed Masjid. For Ahmedabad ”, which was bound for Ahmedabad since 2002, we will have to begin journey! In this Godhra train burning incident them 3 days to whatever they want,..